There are several differences between the storytellers of each narrative. However, the similarities between the two are amazing. Both the Tell Tale Heart and The Black Cat open in a manner that is quit typical of Poe ‘s plant. Both narratives seem to hold an nameless storyteller who claims to be absolutely sane and rational ; yet the mode of Poe ‘s authorship within these two plants seem to turn out otherwise. Thus an component of uncertainness is added to each narrative by manner of the undependable storyteller. In The Tell-Tale Heart the undependable storyteller Begins by saying, “ True! – nervous- really, really awfully nervous. I had been and am but why will you say that I am huffy? The disease had sharpened my senses not- destroyed-not dulled them. Above all was the sense of hearing ague. I heard all things in the Eden and in the Earth. I heard many things in snake pit. How so am I huffy? Hearken and detect how healthily-how calmly I can state you the whole narrative ” ( p.702 ) . Here we see that the storyteller makes a supplication to the reader seeking to carry him/her into thought that he is otherwise anything but “ huffy ” . It is obvious that the storyteller is an undependable beginning who seems to be showing some kind of mental unwellness as he claims to hear all things within the heavenly and earthly kingdom. The storyteller states that he is traveling to state a narrative in which he will support his saneness. He presents his ego defence against insanity in footings of over acuteness of the senses and perceptual experience. This can be seen as he utters, “ It took me an hr to put my whole caput within the gap so far that I could see the old adult male as he lay upon his bed. Hour angle! – would a lunatic have been so wise as this? / I saw it with perfect distinctness/precisely upon that damned topographic point ” ( p.702-703 ) . He so continues in seeking to carry the reader and convert his ego of non being huffy. The lone thing that he admits to is that he is so really nervous.
In The Black Cat, we can see similar actions in the storyteller as that of the storyteller in The Tell-Tale Heart. The narrative foremost opens as the storyteller provinces, ” I neither expect nor solicit belief. Mad so would I be to anticipate it, in a instance where my very senses reject their ain grounds. Yet huffy I am non ” ( p.705 ) . Although this storyteller claims that he is non looking for anyone to believe his narrative, his first statement allows the reader to presume that he is an undependable storyteller due to the fact that he wanted to state his narrative on the Eve of his decease. Therefore his positions of the narrative may possibly be considered to be distorted. The storyteller claims that he is non huffy and he is certain that people, harmonizing to Howard, will see his narrative as a sequence of ordinary events yet the storyteller implies that there is a intimation of supernatural in the narrative that he is about to state. “ I seized him/he inflicted a rebuff lesion upon my manus with his teeth/the rage of a devil immediately possessed me. I knew myself no longer. My original psyche seemed, at one time, seemed to take its flight from my organic structure ” ( p.706 ) . This statement entirely is adequate to convert the reader that the storyteller is so insane or huffy and may endure from some kind of mental impairment.
Even though there are discontinue a few similarities among the two storytellers, differences are present. The difference among the two is in the storyteller ‘s purpose of the slaying and how the storytellers were caught. In The Tell Tale Heart the storyteller planned his slaying for a really long clip waiting on the sly for the right clip to do his move. “ It was impossible to state how first the thought entered my encephalon ; but, one time conceived, it haunted me twenty-four hours and night/ every dark merely at 12 I looked in upon him while he slept ” ( p.702 ) . The storyteller admits to cunningly waiting in the old adult male ‘s house, stalking him twenty-four hours and dark. The storyteller even goes every bit far as to even chortle at the old adult male when his pollex by chance slipped off the lantern to make a little noise. Knowing that the old adult male could non kip because he was atrocious, the storyteller waited still another hr before he went through with his program. It was so because of the old adult male ‘s beating bosom that the storyteller decided that it was clip. After killing the old adult male he dismantled his organic structure and buried him underneath the floor boards but because of his heightened senses he was unable to separate between existent and fanciful sounds in which he thought he heard the whipping of the old adult male ‘s bosom coming up through the floor. This premeditated slaying turned around as the storyteller was forced to state on his ego of fright that the constabulary would happen out.
In The Black Cat the storyteller murdered with no planning but in a minute of unsighted fury. One twenty-four hours while go toing